Season 1, Episode 3

1. I'd Do Anything for Love...

Elmer's transition out of the Amish leads to an unsavory addiction, Laurie struggles converting to Judaism, and Ashley sets out to ease tensions.

2. Love Stinks

Kris, a Pentecostal preachers' son, grapples with his family's disapproval of his Muslim girlfriend's religion.

3. Love is a Battlefield

Ashley's plan to bring Mohammed and her family together backfires, and tensions rise when Kris's dad pushes salvation onto Lensa.

4. Tainted Love

Mohammed confronts Ashley's sister, Eli and Laurie butt heads when Laurie won't wear her Star of David necklace, and Lensa storms out of church.

5. Can You Feel the Love Tonight?

Lindsey and Elmer head into Amish country to reconcile with his family and Kris's dad pushes Lensa too far.

6. How Deep Is Your Love

Mohammed gives Ashley an ultimatum, tensions rise at Eli and Laurie's housewarming party, and Kris is faced with a life-changing decision. 

7. You Give Love a Bad Name

Ashley and Mohammed seek marriage counseling, Laurie receives upsetting news, and Lensa confronts Kris after finding troubling messages on his phone.

8. The Things You Do for Love

Lindsey makes a shocking discovery, Laurie's conversion hits a roadblock, Lensa makes a jaw-dropping decision, and Ashley doubts her conversion.

1. I'd Do Anything for Love...

Elmer's transition out of the Amish leads to an unsavory addiction, Laurie struggles converting to Judaism, and Ashley sets out to ease tensions.

2. Love Stinks

Kris, a Pentecostal preachers' son, grapples with his family's disapproval of his Muslim girlfriend's religion.

3. Love is a Battlefield

Ashley's plan to bring Mohammed and her family together backfires, and tensions rise when Kris's dad pushes salvation onto Lensa.

4. Tainted Love

Mohammed confronts Ashley's sister, Eli and Laurie butt heads when Laurie won't wear her Star of David necklace, and Lensa storms out of church.

5. Can You Feel the Love Tonight?

Lindsey and Elmer head into Amish country to reconcile with his family and Kris's dad pushes Lensa too far.

6. How Deep Is Your Love

Mohammed gives Ashley an ultimatum, tensions rise at Eli and Laurie's housewarming party, and Kris is faced with a life-changing decision. 

7. You Give Love a Bad Name

Ashley and Mohammed seek marriage counseling, Laurie receives upsetting news, and Lensa confronts Kris after finding troubling messages on his phone.

8. The Things You Do for Love

Lindsey makes a shocking discovery, Laurie's conversion hits a roadblock, Lensa makes a jaw-dropping decision, and Ashley doubts her conversion.