Season 1, Episode 5

1. The Deep End of Envy

When a former athlete turns up dead in Osmun Lake, investigators uncover secrets, lies and jealousy as they search for who wanted him gone — and why.

2. Horror on the Hudson

When a pregnant mother surfaces in the Hudson River, NYPD suspects foul play. As they dig deeper, they uncover a killer who's closer than they think.

3. The Blue Room

Teens on a scavenger hunt find a suitcase of body parts. Another washes ashore, launching a frantic hunt to solve a double murder in Seattle’s waters.

4. Lady in the Lake

In 1985, police find a blood-soaked car and search for a missing 20-year-old. Days later, her body surfaces in Lake Springfield — and the hunt begins.

5. Still Waters Silent Killer

A tub with a human leg surfaces in Alum Creek. Police find footage of the killing, but the twisted motive stays as murky as the water that hid it.

6. Blood in the River

Police find a gold SUV near a Washington river. Later, a chilling discovery shatters Camas, sparking a murder probe that points to a deadly dispute.

7. A Killing Off Cape May

The discovery of a dead body off the shore of Cape May sends shockwaves through the community.

1. The Deep End of Envy

When a former athlete turns up dead in Osmun Lake, investigators uncover secrets, lies and jealousy as they search for who wanted him gone — and why.

2. Horror on the Hudson

When a pregnant mother surfaces in the Hudson River, NYPD suspects foul play. As they dig deeper, they uncover a killer who's closer than they think.

3. The Blue Room

Teens on a scavenger hunt find a suitcase of body parts. Another washes ashore, launching a frantic hunt to solve a double murder in Seattle’s waters.

4. Lady in the Lake

In 1985, police find a blood-soaked car and search for a missing 20-year-old. Days later, her body surfaces in Lake Springfield — and the hunt begins.

5. Still Waters Silent Killer

A tub with a human leg surfaces in Alum Creek. Police find footage of the killing, but the twisted motive stays as murky as the water that hid it.

6. Blood in the River

Police find a gold SUV near a Washington river. Later, a chilling discovery shatters Camas, sparking a murder probe that points to a deadly dispute.

7. A Killing Off Cape May

The discovery of a dead body off the shore of Cape May sends shockwaves through the community.